Some projects attempt to combine behavior change and par. Sen argues that economic development should expand valuable freedoms. Sen s capability approach in its normative developmental aspect, is mainly concerned with practical incremental improvements. Amartya sens capability approach and social justice in. The capability approach ca developed by amartya sen focuses on the enhancement of peoples capabilities, i. It only provides a general framework, and not a fully fleshedout theory. However, sen s capability approach does not provide a readymade recipe that we can apply to study gender inequality. Applications of the capabilities approach to poverty measurement and gender issues. Furthermore, both human rights and capabilities have to depend on the process of public reasoning. Pdf sens capability approach and gender inequality.
Sens family was from wari and manikganj, dhaka, both in presentday bangladesh. What is the capability approach its core, rationale. In this paper, the capability approach advocated by amartya sen is applied to evaluate a community bus service. Sen s capability approach arose from a dissatisfaction with both of subjective states and command over resources as concepts or measures of wellbeing or advantage, and from the wish for a concept that presents persons as reasoners with the right to make choices. The capability approach contains three central concepts.
The capabilities approach, adult community learning and. The capability approach also referred to as the capabilities approach was initially conceived in the 1980s as an approach to welfare economics. Another approach is to consider its capability, in terms of the freedom and ability of people to achieve. Rabindranath tagore gave amartya sen his name bengali. Essays on amartya sens capability approach repub, erasmus. He used the labor market as an example, saying that while working is a functioning, the opportunity to work is an element of a persons. It discusses the development and structure of sens account, how it relates to other ethical approaches, and its main contributions and criticisms. The most formal technical elaboration of sens capability approach. One of the most significant theoretical contributions to welfare analysis across a range of disciplines has been the development of the capabilities framework by sen and others. Amartya sen was born in a bengali hindu baidya family in bengal, british india, in rabindranath tagores university shantiniketan, modern day west bengal, india. Commonly, though, economists defend markets strictly on grounds of.
Amartya sen pioneered the approach and several others have significantly developed it. Amartya sens capability approach is increasingly influential in the literature of development economics. Development as capability expansion, journal of development planning 19. To identify the main functions relating to capability. The attempt to merge economic analysis with practical politicsto view economic activity in its political context. Dagsvik 20 argued that in sens framework, capabilities or the capability set represent the opportunities to achieve functionings. Advocated and developed by amartya sen in a variety of writings, this approach attempts to define wellbeing in an objective way, by identifying a set of core human capabilities that are critical to full human functioning and assessing wellbeing and the success of development policies by the degree to which the.
The core focus of the capability approach is on what individuals. Pdf development as freedom, in the words of amartya sen 1999. An ebook reader can be a software application for use on a computer such as microsoft s free reader application, or a booksized computer that is used solely as a reading device such as nuvomedia s rocket ebook. Merging capabilities and livelihoods ecology and society. The methodology of public scrutiny draws on rawlsian understanding of objectivity in ethics, but the impartiality that is needed cannot be confined within the borders of a nation. A functioning is a valuable activity or state that makes up peoples wellbeing.
We describe amartya sens capability approach to welfare evaluation in the language of standard welfare economics, and assess to what extent it provides a genuine alternative for individual welfare measurement and policy evaluation. The capability approach has been advanced in somewhat different directions by martha nussbaum, who has used the capability approach as the foundation for a partial theory of justice. Number 7 is penumbral, and numbers 8 and 9 lie outside his version. To clarify the concept of capability in the view of travel. This article argues that amartya sens capabilities approach to development should. It is argued that the capability approach can reflect the many ways that human lives are blighted and that it thus offers a promising framework for poverty analysis.
Despite its attractions which the article acknowledges the capability approach. The capability approach as a human development paradigm and its critiques nuno ornelas martins department of economics and business, university of the azores, portugal keywords. Attempts to operationalise sens capability approach this section discusses work that has been done to operationalise sens ca for practical. Capability approach pioneered by amartya sen has been a new milestone for analyzing poverty through gender perspective. A capability is a persons ability to do valuable acts or reach valuable states of being. Sens capability approach is a helpful intervention in the discourses of mainstream western welfare economics and moral philosophy. As stated in the 1990 human development report, human development is a process of enlarging peoples choices undp 1990, p.
But a generally poor quality education, or experiences of harassment at school can be a serious lifelong disadvantage. Pdf sens capability approach and nussbaums capability ethic. This is quite problematic, as sen has developed his capability approach. Sen describes it as representing the various combinations of functionings beings. The capability approach is a theoretical framework that entails two core normative claims. In quality of life sen pointed out that he had not used the term basic capabilities in his dewey lectures, nor in commodities and capabilities, in order to avoid confining the capability approach only to the analysis of basic capabilities sen 1993 sen ak capability and well. The success of a country can be measured by such as gross national product gnp per capita, health of its people, education levels and so on. Sens arguments about equality seem to have the following bearing on issues of social justice and public policy. It has contributed to development discourse by strengthening the multidimensional approach to poverty analysis and stressing. Since the introduction of the approach, numerous scholars from various. Sens capability approach and democracy in this chapter i argue for two claims. Developed over the 1980s by amartya sen 1980, 1985, 1989, 1999 in a series of publications on quality of. This compelling book introduces nobel laureate amartya sens capability approach and explores its significance for theory, policy and practice in education. Development in practice sens capability approach as a.
Contributors hail from the uk, usa, australia, italy and mexico. Sen s arguments about equality seem to have the following bearing on issues of social justice and public policy. Operationalizing amartya sens capability approach xh. Sens capability approach arose from a dissatisfaction with both of subjective states and command over resources as concepts or measures of wellbeing or advantage, and from the wish for a concept that presents persons as reasoners with the right to make choices. Jun, 2008 ebook is an electronic version of a traditional print book that can be read by using a personal computer or by using an ebook reader. To view the pdf, you must log in or become a member. One of the crucial questions that sen has not answered is which capabilities are relevant for assessing inequality.
Economists are generally alive to the virtues of markets, and few since the collapse of communism have a good word to say about central planning. Buy amartya sens capability approach and social justice in education 2007 by walker, melanie isbn. Within ca, then, evaluation of a public good, such as education, needs to assess the ways in which social inequalities rooted in the cultural or structural context affect peoples abilities to use commodities to enhance their capability set, or combinations of. The first section outlines the main components of the capability approach. The concept has directly influenced the workings of both the international united nations development programme and the uk s domestic equality and human rights commission. It is argued that it is essentially a liberalindividualist concept. The capability approach stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Motivated by the claim that freedom should play a key role in social evaluation, the capabilities framework suggests that we consider what it is that people are free to do, as well as what they actually do. An introduction 15 pdf version matches the latest version of this entry. This article focuses on the philosophical aspects of the capability approach and its foundations in the work of amartya sen. Sen s capability approach does not explicitly allow that formal education may not always operate as an unqualified good. Sens capability approach is grounded in his analysis of famine and. Functionings and capabilities department of economics.
The right to the city and capability approach combined econstor. The paper ends with a discussion of the findings and a conclusion. Sens idea of justice 2009 moves beyond capability approach which articulated the space in which to evaluate wellbeing, and towards a welfare economics, with multiple dimensions in capability space, as well as principles, and processes. First, i contend that sens capability approach to social ethics and international development permits or, better, requires democracy conceived as public deliberation. The paper assesses sens more abstract version of capabilities theory, nussbaums more substantive aristotelian version and attempts to apply such conceptions to womens lives. One might be interested in combining all of the relevant dimensions to. You can also read more about the friends of the sep society. Foundational issues are addressed criticallydimensions. An especially accessible and succinct account of the capability approach to human development.
The book looks particularly at questions concerning the education of children, gender equality, and higher education. The foundation of sens and nussbaums development ethic, part 2, women, culture, and. In the second section i analyze, this chapter includes a substantial revision and modification of sections 1. Sabina alkire shows how nobel prizewinning economist amartya sens capability approach can be coherentlyand practicallyput to work in poverty reduction activities. Nussbaums formulation university of michigan dearborn. For an introduction to the capability approach and how the approach has.
Nussbaum s approach is rather more utopian in that it demands the full implementation of minimal justice achievement of the minimum thresholds of all fundamental capabilities for all, and this is specified so demandingly that no country yet meets it though she has suggested that finland may be close. Human development and the capability approachtheoretical framework and policy agenda amartya sens capability approach has emerged as a leading theoretical framework in economics of welfare and development. The second adapts the capability approach to the elaboration of a. Sen s capability approach as a framework to the practice of development capability approach, in order to contribute to articulating a development approach that radicalises the practice of development. The approach that will be used here, which is sometimes called the capability approach, sees human life as a set of doings and beingswe may call them functioningsand it relates the evaluation of the quality of life to the assessment of the capability to function. In this text we will take sen s capability approach as our starting point, and discuss nussbaums work when it criticises, divers from, or adds to sen s work. This pdf version matches the latest version of this entry. The capability approach is an evaluative framework for individual. An ebook reader can be a software application for use on a computer such as microsofts free reader application, or a booksized computer that is used solely as a reading device such as nuvomedias rocket ebook. Sens capability approach as a framework to the practice. Pdf the paper assesses sens more abstract version of capabilities theory. A martya sens wideranging book grasps a point ignored by many econo mists. In this approach, amartya sen and martha nussbaum bring together a range of ideas that were previously excluded from or inadequately formulated in traditional approaches to the economics of welfare.
Sen argues that an individuals welfare should not be measured in terms of her income, but in terms what she can actually do or be, her capabilities. Amartya sens capability approach and social justice in education. First of all, i outline what the term cultural justice means in this paper, because 1 the slightly different version was presented under the title cultural justice, basic income and capability approach at 4th international conference on the capability approach, 47, september 2004, pavia. The concept has directly influenced the workings of both the international united nations development programme and the uks domestic equality and human rights commission. In terms of this approach, a capability can be defined as the freedom to choose to do or be something, and a functioning can be defined as a measurable, objective capability that an individual has already achieved alkire, 2005. Sens capability approach is a helpful intervention in the discourses of.
The capability approach as a human development paradigm. Sens capability approach and gender inequality request pdf. Why the capability approach journal of human development. Human dignity in the capability approach rutger claassen. The capability approach is a theoretical framework that puts emphasis on the importance of freedom to achieve wellbeing, where freedom to achieve wellbeing is understood in terms of peoples opportunities to choose and how to be. Some refelctions 2016 human development report office 2 think piece s. He obtained a phd in economics from the london school of economics and worked at the bangladesh institute of development. Osmani is professor of development economics at ulster university, uk.
The capability approach the capability approach is used by social scientists, lawyers and philosophers, in a variety of. We describe amartya sen s capability approach to welfare evaluation in the language of standard welfare economics, and assess to what extent it provides a genuine alternative for individual welfare measurement and policy evaluation. A summary is provided of each paper that was found to use sens ca, as well as a comparative analysis in tabular format. The literature on applications of the socalled capability approach of amartya sen and martha nussbaum is extensive, but it is only recently that some have argued that its application to the analysis of disability would be a great advantage over existing analyses, and in particular preferable to the model of functioning and disability found in the world health organizations. The capability approach also referred to as the capabilities approach is an economic theory conceived in the 1980s as an alternative approach to welfare economics. Finally, i will criticize this way of using the concept of dignity and raise some questions section 3. Sens capability approach as a framework to the practice of development alexandre apsan frediani online publication date. An introduction 15 sen s critique and formulation 159 4.
768 729 1030 1059 799 1031 12 1208 810 771 957 1234 679 1070 1257 858 624 155 600 866 26 331 1314 1334 523 981 1055 1471 1385 649 218 414 933 1299 1162 1168 78 558 350 650 458 16 1369